Ikea Hack for Settlers of Catan

About a month ago, my eight-year-old complained that it’s not fair that she has to go to church on Sunday morning when she is tired from watching movies on Saturday night. I can’t see the connection myself, given that she’s up to all hours of the night reading anyway, but I was fine with switching movie night to Thursdays instead.

At first, both girls were happy with this new night (because I’m pretty sure the whole conversation took place on a Thursday afternoon), but when Saturday evening rolled around, they were both upset that there was nothing to look forward to. And that there was no popcorn on the agenda.

Enter family game night.

We’ve been collecting a lot of board games over the year – mostly cooperative games for Harbour from Peaceable Kingdom. I wanted something a bit more challenging to play withย River so I sent James out to buy Settlers of Catan Jr, which is a simplified version of the regular Settlers of Catan.ย It was instant love.

The rules were confusing at first, but only for a moment. Once you start playing, it’s easy to catch on. River and I played on Saturday night, and then we played again on Sunday night, this time with James joining us. It was fun, and I was happy.

We played each Saturday night for a few weeks in a row. Sometimes five-year-old Harbour joined in as the designated “ghost pirate” mover; other times she sat beside me and we played one of her games at the same time.

After about a month of playing the Junior version, I brought the regular version of Settlers upstairs from the basement. James and I bought it years ago, but I honestly don’t know if we’ve ever even played it at all. I went to the Settlers website and watched the little game demo, and then I showed River how the game works. Since we’d been playing the Junior version for a month, she picked up the rules without any trouble at all. We made some popcorn and started a game.

And it was great — I’ve been looking forward to playing board games as a family ever since River was born, and sitting around the table with my girls and my husband was such a satisfying experience.

We all loved the game – EXCEPT FOR ONE THING.

In Settlers of Catan, you arrange the hexagonal pieces differently each time you play so that your game is always fresh and new. But the pieces slide around when you bump them and it’s SOOOOO irritating. Especially when your five-year-old is “helping” you put pieces on the board.

Fellow Settlers fans: I know this picture makes you cringe.

Settlers of Catan: How to Keep the Pieces Together

Last week we went to Ikea and James was determined to buy a piece of glass to set over the board.

Really? A random piece of glass? And just what would I do with it the rest of the week? I had visions of one-year-old Forest finding it and running through the house, holding the glass up high over his head while the rest of us ran after him. But James had decided that we could not play another game without some sort of board protector and so every time we passed a piece of glass, he measured it to see if it was big enough. I thought I was doomed when he found something that could work beautifully – until we arrived in the picture frame department.

That’s where we saw the glass-free Saxnas frame, which is as cheap as they come. We paid $5.99 Canadian, so given the exchange rate, I can only imagine that Ikea in the US actually pays it’s customers to take them home.

On Saturday night, we set up our Catan board with the hexagonal shapes and the number discs, then we placed the frame carefully over top to keep everything in place. It fit perfectly. Like, so perfectly that every future Settlers game should come with a $6 gift card to Ikea. We played our settlement and road pieces right on top of the plastic and everything underneath stayed put. If you play Settlers of Catan, get to an Ikea and get yourself a Saxnas frame right away.

For the rest of the week, the frame hangs on the wall in our hallway. We decided that the winner gets to put a picture behind it for the family to enjoy until the next game — I thought the girls would get a kick out of adding some of their artwork. But as luck would have it, James won the game on Saturday and he picked a picture of Steve McQueen.

So this is what I see every time I leave the bathroom:

I’m not sure how I’m going to top that, but I have at least a week to figure it out. Any suggestions?


Comments

26 responses to “Ikea Hack for Settlers of Catan”

  1. Hannelle Avatar
    Hannelle

    I love this so much! I usually spend my entire Settlers game readjusting the pieces over and over and over again…

    1. I was surprised at how much nicer it was to play the game without having to worry about the board pieces constantly!

  2. Such a good idea, I only wish our Ikea wasn’t 2 hours away! Also, I love that the winner gets to choose what goes in the frame!

    1. 2 hours away! Wow, I totally take my Ikea for granted!

    2. Roseanne Avatar
      Roseanne

      You can buy the plastic pieces that are made to use with the game on EBay
      just do a search for Catan and they will come up (along with extra different colored pieces). Also to make the game a little more random when you put the discs on leave the number side down until everyone has placed their first round pieces. Then flip them over.
      Another game that might work well for the kids is Carcassone. It’s placing tiles to make cities and roads and fields Board ends up different every time.

  3. Love this! I’m going to Ikea then finding the game to purchase. I’ve always wanted a games night but I just can’t get my family involved. Maybe a nice picture frame for their artwork would do the trick.

    1. I love playing games with my family – I’m glad that River is finally old enough to play good ones! I remember playing Monopoly for hours and your house when I was young – I’m glad my kids haven’t discovered that one yet. ๐Ÿ˜‰ Even better will be when the kids can play cards. ๐Ÿ˜€

  4. Brilliant! This is definitely the most elegant solution I’ve seen yet. Too bad my kids are still too young for Catan. They’d probably just throw the roads everywhere and make lots of sheep noises while running up and down the hallway. Which they’d probably do anyway. ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Hey, thanks for stopping by my blog! I’m looking forward to trying out Stratos – will my 8yo be too young for it?

      1. Depends on how much you care about following all the rules! I’ve taught kids that young and they got the basics of it just fine. Even without playing with the full rule set, you can still have fun anyway!

        1. Awesome – I can’t wait to try it out!

  5. Looks great! I always like being creative with my board games! ๐Ÿ™‚

  6. Frank Cozens Avatar
    Frank Cozens

    Settlers is a great game! We have bought several extensions over the years, and still enjoy playing. The Ikea solution is cheap and elegant. Many players have made extremely complex boards with all sorts of compartments for the game componants. All seem to have some advantages and disadvantages. Cost is a factor with many boards sold by different manufacturers. In the meantime, enjoy playing!

    1. Tamara Avatar
      Tamara

      Thank you for visiting my blog! I’m sure that as my younger kids get older and play with us, we’ll look for something more awesome that screams hard-core gaming family lol. Right now we needed something cheap and easy, knowing that my one year old is likely to destroy anything more complex. ๐Ÿ˜€

  7. Steph Avatar
    Steph

    Would the frame accommodate when playing with 5-6 players and board is bigger?

    1. Tamara Avatar
      Tamara

      I don’t know because I’ve never tried with 5-6 players. If the board gets much wider, than I don’t think it would work. If it gets longer, than maybe. LOL, okay not super helpful. ๐Ÿ˜› We used the Seafarers expansion pack (scenario 1) on the weekend and we covered the board with the plastic from the frame but didn’t use the frame itself. The edges of the board stuck out but it still worked well enough to keep everything in place.

  8. They actually make a plastic board for the game that holds all the pieces in place:
    https://www.amazon.com/Official-Settlers-Catan-Board-Plastic/dp/B00ETFTX9Q/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1467837308&sr=8-1&keywords=settlers+of+catan+board
    It costs a lot more than the Ikea picture frame, but it works really well and breaks down so it is easy to store when not in use.

    1. Tamara Avatar
      Tamara

      That looks pretty awesome! Does it keep the pieces in place when you need to stop for the night?

  9. Elisabeth Avatar
    Elisabeth

    It looks like a good idea…

    Until you become a ‘real’* Settlers fan, and start playing Seafarers or C&K. The Fog Island or anything involving the C&K progress cards are impossible with a board cover.

    * note the quotation marks. I have absolutely nothing against Base Game, but once you expand, base game is just something you play when there’s newbies around. And even then I usually start them on Seafarers as it’s harder to get stuck and locked in. Even kids.

    1. Tamara Avatar
      Tamara

      We’ve only been playing for a few months – and that includes the junior version – so you’re right, we’re total newbies. We played the first scenario from the Seafarers expansion pack last week and we just put the plastic on top of the board without the frame. It worked okay, kept everything in place. I kind of want to search for a larger frame because it’s been working so well for us, but we’ll probably just be cheap and keep using what we’ve got.

      1. Elisabeth Avatar
        Elisabeth

        It’s not about the frame size (although… a frame big enough for Greater Catan 6p would be Expensive) , it’s about the mechanics of having the board covered.
        The first scenario of SF is possible, yes. It’s pretty much just an introductory board to get to know the rules. But, a few of the further (actual) scenarios have mystery hexes, hexes turned over face down. As soon as you reach them by boat, you may flip them over and there’s either a water or land tile you uncover. In C&K, there’s a card that allows you to swap 2 number chits mid-game (We’ve had games where there was a swap war, the same 2 chits were swapped over a dozen times). It’s impossible to do those actions when there’s a plexiglass sheet covering your board. – Unless you lift the glass, but that would require taking pictures to re-set all the pieces after they inevitably shifted during the lift. In a game with both SF and C&K that would be MAJORLY disruptive to the gameplay.

        However, in time (and especially if you play more modular games) you become desensitized to the shifting. It’s a modular game, which is the charm of the game, but, it shifts. Making sure the borders are flat and sturdy though (and your version has borders, my base game doesn’t, only SF), really helps. It looks like one of your borders is curling and therefore letting go. Try putting them on a level surface with a few HEAVY books on top.

        1. Tamara Avatar
          Tamara

          Wow, I can’t wait to play all the different scenarios. We’re not at that point yet so for now we’ll be fine with our $6 plastic frame. ๐Ÿ™‚ I’ll try to flatten out the borders as you suggested – I never noticed that!

  10. Nyahm Avatar
    Nyahm

    Another fun project for the family can be making your own 3D Catan tiles ^.^
    http://imgur.com/a/3lQz1
    There’s a tutorial pdf in the description of one of the images (5th image from top).

    1. Tamara Avatar
      Tamara

      That looks seriously cool!!!

  11. Shane Gordon Avatar
    Shane Gordon

    I bought a plastic board that holds in the hexagons and roads. Pay $50 and you have the plastic board for the regular game and the expansion for 5 to 6 players.

  12. Cool idea – as you play catan you will want to start mixing up the board randomly so this would hinder that. Not to mention expansions.

Leave a Reply to Nyahm Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *